But then the next day, it turns out to be Sofia's birthday for the 38th time! If that incident wasn't Cedric's fault, then how did it happen in the first place? After the witches see Calista try to be scary with her Giggling Goblin giggle, Lucinda asks Sofia if they should tell Calista if her Giggling Goblin giggle is more cute than scary. With the Goblin's help, they get more candy from Mr P. To make this fair, Sofia holds auditions for an animal helper. They are heading for a party hosted by Cordelia's friend Muldo the Magnificent. However, the faun doubts that she is special. Sofia dismisses it as it will make her nervous.
Along the journey, Hildegard tries to take the credit for finding the pyramid all for herself without any team efforts. They're so busy fighting that they're not even thinking about what Lucinda wants. Sofia tells Amber they are children and that their mother is just trying to protect them. Sofia agrees to take Amber with her, and they meet an enthusiastic flying unicorn named Skye and Windwalkers who are Protectors of the Mystic Isles. How can the family get out of this? When Sofia finally makes dragon fire at school, Twitch steals Sofia's fire, and Prisma uses it to open the secret passageway! In Amber's room, Amber rants how their mother is always telling her what to do and treats them like children. She and Sofia decide to sail out to the Cloudless Sea but only if Miranda joins them.
Thanks to the Locket of Vor, she heads to Royal Prep to get the Hiddne Spindle that Aurora pricked her finger on. In order to make friends, Crackle lies about Sofia being the Royal Dragon of Enchancia. Sofia is able to grant these stories happy endings and chooses the story of Mazzimo, Minimus' older brother. Sofia leads her family on a brave expedition to find him, and shows Amber that spending the holiday with loved ones is better than any present. What's going on, and who's the real noble knight? For the very first time in his life, Desmond finds himself struggling in school! How will Sofia stop her? Princess Elena from the Kingdom of Avalor has been magically trapped inside Sofia's amulet for forty-one years, waiting for another Princess to set her free, and Sofia is up to the task! James himself is having trouble making friends because he was caught standing in Itching Ivy, and nobody wants to get near him.
She wants to tell Sofia that she doesn't want to switch schools, but she doesn't know how. Sofia thinks an old idea would be better for Jun, and Wu-Chang says that a Men-Saing herb can cure the summer sniffles. Mazzimo has been captured by Prince Roderick of Borrea. When she wishes to relive her birthday again, Ruby's fairy godmother, Tizzy, grants her wish. She attends a preparatory school under the tutelage of fairies in order to train for her new role as a princess. The group lands at Dragonhold to get candy from.
Sofia discovers what has happened and tries to sacrifice her amulet, only to have it taken by Wormwood, resulting in another pegasus chase that ends with the amulet's retrieval. . Amber is going to help her get ready, but she's being really pushy by blowing her whistle at her. To break the curse, Charlotte needs to be true friends with Morris. Crackle really wants to go, but she needs a dragon buddy to take with her, and she doesn't have one. The group then steps up for the Haunted Hay Ride where they meet. With the royals' ship sunken, they climb aboard the pirate ship, and now they have to help the pirates look for the Golden Maiden.
Sofia tells her she does not have to prove anything and just needs to be herself. Sofia's new white dress gets stained with juice from a propeller plum, and the animals accidentally rip it. To have everyone spend more time together, Miranda books a vacation to the Flying Elephant rainforest. The trio climb on board the ship they helped and meet and his crew, a band of inept pirates. Sofia tells Indigo to undo her hex and bring Calista back, but she refuses.
Along the way, Cedric takes his first step towards the light when she soothes his stress. But during the mission, Amber has become jealous that Sofia has a magical amulet, and she wants one too. Meanwhile, whenever everyone sees anything interesting in the park, Hildegard decides that she wants it, and Miss Elodie stops King Henrik from disturbing the animals. Sofia is excited until Princess Hildegard tells her that King Roland isn't her real father. After the Goblin takes the witches' wands, Sofia encourages her to execute her plan. With his trust in them restored, Captain Quivers lets Sofia steer the ship and Miranda navigates.
Sofia slides down the stair railing after Miranda. But Amber's desire for a magic amulet of her own makes the mission no easier than it already is. Suddenly, they get attacked by the swordfish who live in the Sea of Swimming Swords, which is what the Sea of Lemming Hordes is, proving that Sofia is right about Captain Quiver getting the words wrong. Earlier today, Charlotte was rude to a goblin named Morris when he asked if he could come to her royal ball and she wound up hurting his feelings. James stows away in Sofia's coach, so he can join her on the mission and practice for his Junior Knight retest. Can Sofia and Calista help the latter's mother and uncle get along? The directions to it are in an ancient shanty, which they sing in a way that Miranda and the girls cannot make heads or tails of. Sofia and some of the other royals are starting Majestic Hall, and they've gotten off to a good start, but not Prince Desmond, the star student of Royal Prep.
Disguises as a weasel, Twitch tries to get Sofia to let him be her animal helper, but Sofia declines. When the other witches arrive, Calista offers to lead them through the maze. P since he is famous for handing out the best candy. Along the way she discovers what it means to be a great adventurer! Afterwards, the witches reconcile with Calista and tell her that she made this the best Halloween ever. Meanwhile, Wormwood keeps complaining about how goofy and bumbling Cedric is. Unfortunately, driving the ghosts away causes the carriage to go out of control and crash in the Dreary Woods. Calista declares Halloween to be her favorite holiday, to which Cordelia concurs that Calista makes her read the Ghastly Guide to Halloween to her every night before bed.